Optimal Reach MediaBook a call

Insights · · Optimal Reach Media

What to Say When a Reporter Calls: A Guide for Doctors and Attorneys

A reporter is on the line. Here's what doctors and attorneys should say first, what to leave out, and what off the record really means.

Key point: When a reporter calls, you do not have to answer on the spot. Ask what the story is about and when the deadline is, call back with one clear point, and keep patients and case details out of it.

The best thing to say when a reporter calls is a question, not an answer. Find out what the story is about, who else is in it, and when the deadline is. Then take a few minutes, write down the one point you want to make, and call back before that deadline.

For doctors and attorneys, that pause matters more than it does for most people. You are trusted with private information, and the rules about what you can share are stricter than they are for a shop owner or a startup founder. A friendly, prepared answer protects your patients and clients, and it makes you the expert reporters want to call again.

The first two minutes

Most calls come at a bad time: between patients, in the hallway outside a courtroom, or right as you leave for the day. You can be warm and still be careful. A simple script works:

  • "Thanks for calling. What's the story about?"
  • "Who else are you talking to?"
  • "What's your deadline?"
  • "Let me pull my thoughts together and call you back by then."

That is not stalling. Reporters work on tight timelines, and a source who calls back on time with a clear, usable answer is a source they remember. What hurts is guessing on the first call and then trying to walk it back.

Pick one point and say it plainly

Before you call back, decide on the one thing you want readers or viewers to understand. Write it in a sentence or two, in words a patient or a client would use. Leave out the jargon, the citations and the footnotes. If the reporter asks something you cannot or should not answer, say so briefly and return to your point.

Keep it brief. A long, careful explanation gives a reporter more to trim, and the line that survives may not be the one you meant to stress. If the call turns into an on-air interview, our guide on how to prepare for a TV news interview covers the rest.

For doctors: talk about the condition, not the patient

Health care has the clearest line. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services says that, generally, the HIPAA Privacy Rule does not permit health care providers to disclose patient information to the media without a signed authorization from the patient. HHS also says it is not enough to ask the media to blur faces or alter voices after the fact.

The good news is that the same guidance says providers can still tell the media about their treatment services and programs. So a reporter's call is a chance to explain:

  • What a condition is and who tends to get it
  • How a treatment works and what recovery looks like
  • What a seasonal trend means for families, and when to see someone

What you leave out is anything about a specific person. If a reporter mentions a patient by name, do not confirm or deny that the person is in your care. Bring in your practice's privacy officer before you say yes to anything that involves a patient, a filming request, or a visit to your office.

If you plan to film in your own practice, the same HHS page says that when patients will be identified, or patient information might be visible during filming, the provider needs a business associate agreement with the film crew. Ask about that before anyone sets up a camera.

For attorneys: know what Rule 3.6 allows

Lawyers have their own guardrails. In Pennsylvania, Rule 3.6 of the Rules of Professional Conduct says a lawyer involved in a matter should not make a public statement that is substantially likely to materially prejudice the proceeding. The same rule lists what a lawyer may generally say, including:

  • The claim, offense or defense involved
  • Information contained in a public record
  • That an investigation is in progress
  • The scheduling or result of any step in litigation

That gives you a useful script for a pending case: what the case is about, what is already public, and what happens next. The rule's own commentary warns about topics like the character or credibility of a party or witness, and, in a criminal case, any opinion on guilt or innocence. Your client's confidences stay with you.

The rule applies to lawyers who are, or have been, involved in the matter. If a reporter calls you as an outside expert on someone else's case, you have more room to explain the law. Plain explanations of what a ruling means for ordinary people are useful to reporters, and they build your reputation as the person who makes the law make sense.

What "off the record" really means

It is tempting to treat "off the record" as a safe word. It is not that simple. The Associated Press tells its reporters that not everyone understands "off the record" or "on background" to mean the same things, and that the ground rules should be set explicitly before the interview. AP defines off the record as information that cannot be used for publication. AP also tells its reporters to assume an interview is on the record unless conditions are agreed at the start.

The safest habit is simple: if you would not want to read it with your name next to it, do not say it. Agree on any ground rules at the start of the call, never in the middle and never after the fact.

Practice before the phone rings

Sounding calm and quotable takes practice: saying your point out loud, handling the awkward question, and hearing how it lands.

We're a Pittsburgh production studio that comes to you, so we can run that practice at your office, or over video if the drive is the wrong fit. Media training starts at $2,500 for an in-person half day, or $1,500 for a virtual half day. If you want to become the doctor or attorney reporters call first, our personal PR work helps you build that reputation week by week. You can also read more about what media training costs in Pittsburgh.

Book a call and tell us what kind of calls you want to be ready for.

Frequently asked questions

What should I say first when a reporter calls?

Be friendly and ask questions before you answer any. Find out what the story is about, who else they are talking to, and when their deadline is. Then offer to call back at a set time.

Is it rude to ask a reporter to call back?

No. Asking for a few minutes to prepare is normal. Ask for the deadline, then call back before it, ideally with your main point written down.

What does off the record mean?

It depends on who you ask, so never assume. The Associated Press defines off the record as information that cannot be used for publication, but it also tells its reporters that people understand these terms differently and to set the ground rules at the start.

Can a doctor talk to a reporter about a patient?

Usually not without the patient's written permission. Talk about the condition, the treatment, or the trend instead of a specific person, and loop in your privacy officer before you agree to anything that involves a patient.

Can a lawyer comment on a case to the press?

Sometimes, within limits. Pennsylvania's Rule 3.6 lets a lawyer in the case state things like the claim, information in a public record, and the scheduling or result of a step in litigation, but bars statements likely to materially prejudice the proceeding.

Related service: Continue with this service

Where to go from here

We are a Pittsburgh production studio, and we come to you. If you want to keep going, start with the work, a call, or the free brand audit.

Free brand audit

A free look at how the brand shows up

We are a Pittsburgh production studio, and we come to you. The free brand audit is a read of the public site. You can close this and keep reading.

Get the free audit